POLDARK (Episode One): My First Impression

Poldark_2015_TV_series_titlecard

Summary: In late 18th-century, Ross Poldark returns to his Cornish tin mines after spending three years in the army to avoid charges of smuggling, leaving behind his sweetheart Elizabeth. On his return, having fought in the American War of Independence, he finds his father dead, his estate in ruins and Elizabeth engaged to his cousin Francis. In need of help he takes on a new kitchen maid, Demelza, after rescuing her from a beating bringing him into conflict with hostile locals.

Episode 1 Recap:

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 3_33_28 PMThe episode opens with Ross Poldark fighting a losing battle in the American Revolution. When the war ends, he returns to Cornwall, England, with a scar on his face and a wounded leg.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_13_03 PMDuring the journey home, he pretends to be asleep while he listens to the whispers among people who have recognized him. Ross learns that his father–the libertine–is dead, and that he has inherited the ancient Poldark land.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_19_55 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_15_37 PMWanting to announce his return from the war, Poldark walks into a dinner gathering at Trenwith House and is overjoyed to see his sweetheart, Elizabeth.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_17_40 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_17_33 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_18_35 PM But he soon learns that the dinner is in celebration of Elizabeth’s engagement to Ross’ cousin, Francis. Her excuse for betraying Ross is understandable: ‘But I thought you were dead!!!’

Now that Elizabeth realizes her mistake, a look of remorse crosses her face, and one gets the sense that she never stopped loving Ross. Too late now.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_23_12 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_25_10 PMTrying not to think of Elizabeth, Ross keeps himself busy. He is determined to make a livelihood from his rotting Nampara estate. His tenants assure him that they’re willing to work for Ross even without pay. It’s clear that the tenants deeply respect him.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_26_56 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_27_06 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_27_14 PMMeanwhile, Elizabeth waits at her home for Ross, hoping to explain to him why she betrayed him. When she hears the rumbling of carriage wheels, thinking it to be her ex-lover, she leaps up onto her feet, smiling and wringing her hands. But, to her disappointment, it’s her fiancé that has arrived. He’s come with ‘good’ news—they’re going to get married sooner than they had originally planned.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_31_23 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_31_33 PMAfter Francis leaves, Elizabeth is about to go look for Ross, but she’s stopped by her mother. Elizabeth is reminded that she is (1) engaged, and that (2) Ross can offer her nothing but “poverty, uncertainty, and a dubious reputation.”

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_30_54 PMRoss’ former classmate George Warleggan, however, seems to think otherwise. For him, there’s something to be gained through Ross Poldark. He speaks with another scheming gentleman about Poldark’s ancient family name and how they should buy his friendship and use him to open doors. Warleggan has the look of a villain about him.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_34_30 PMAs Ross continues to labor away, Elizabeth continues to think of him.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_36_28 PMFrancis, perhaps sensing Elizabeth’s wandering heart, visits to speak with her.

Francis: I cannot promise to be as fascinating as some… But one thing I can promise you… my undying love. And gratitude. But if there is something that still troubles you. If there is something that you wish to tell me…
Elizabeth: There is. I wish to tell you… that I cannot wait to be your wife.

Elizabeth must have realized herself: Ross isn’t husband material.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_40_23 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_39_43 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_39_33 PM When the wedding day arrives, Ross is forced to attend. And as he watches his former sweetheart exchange vows with Francis, Ross remembers the days he and Elizabeth had once spent together.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_44_14 PM Shortly after the wedding, Elizabeth finally has the opportunity to speak with Ross. She apologizes for not having waited for him, but tells him that three years is a long time to wait–especially when everyone thought he was dead.

Throughout her explanation, Ross observes her coolly, as though he doesn’t give a damn.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_47_34 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_47_36 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_46_50 PMHowever, in the next scene, we see Ross binge drinking to numb his misery, and staring down at the ring Elizabeth had given him. He still loves her, but has now lost her. Weaved in with this moment is the scene of the aged Aunt Agatha Poldark looking into the Poldark fortune:

The dark Poldark or the fair?
‘The stronger rises’ as the weaker falls.
For all is fair in love and war.
.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_50_55 PMRoss’ romantic fate changes on market day.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_54_11 PM

Seeing a crowd ahead of him, Ross approaches and discovers that people are waiting to watch a fight between the fierce Dog #1 and the whimpering, gold-furred Dog #2.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_54_36 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_55_16 PMScreenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_55_21 PMAs the dogs are about to fight, someone shrieks, “Hey, that’s my dog!” referring to the frightened Dog #2. Pushing through the crowd is a boy, who looks desperate to rescue the dog. The men push the boy about, then toss him to the ground.

At once, Ross steps in and tries to stop the bullying, but one man interferes. Ross ends up striking the man with his walking-stick (Ross has a wounded leg and needs it to walk).

Elizabeth, who also happened to be present, sees Ross’ violence and looks away.

.

.Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_55_27 PMRoss reaches down to help the thin and filthy boy.

“Have they hurt you, child?” he asks.

But the ‘boy’ turns out to be a woman, and she snaps, “Don’t ‘ee “child” me, mister!”

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_57_45 PM Screenshot - 2015-03-24 , 11_58_41 PM Ross takes her to an inn to give her a warm meal, and as she wolfs it down, he asks the people lingering around: “Anyone know this child?” We learn that the girl (Damelza) is Tom Carne’s daughter from Illugan.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_00_23 AMScreenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_00_09 AM Elizabeth enters the inn to tell Ross that he did good in rescuing the child, but looks hardly pleased to find that the ‘boy’ is actually a woman.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_01_09 AMScreenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_00_39 AMAfter Elizabeth leaves, Ross returns his attention to Damelza. Because her shirt is too large for her, it droops at the back, revealing some pretty bad scars.

Ross: They did hurt you.
Damelza: Not they.
Ross: Then who?
Damelza: Father.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_03_08 AM Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_04_22 AMRoss proves to be a kind-hearted man; he not only offers to take Damelza home, but half-way through their journey, he tells her he’s in need of a kitchen. He is offering her an opportunity to live a life away from her violent father. She immediately accepts the offer, but only if Ross will let her take Garrick with her (Dog #2). He agrees.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_11_03 AMRoss’ decision to employ Damelza stirs up trouble. When Ross meets Elizabeth, she warns Ross that he needs to send Damelza back, as people are quick to judge (people might mistaken Damelza for his mistress). One also gets the sense that Elizabeth is jealous.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_10_48 AM(And Elizabeth has every reason to be jealous, if that is the case. Damelza, after a good scrub, turns out to be a pretty young woman).

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_12_20 AMAnyway. As Elizabeth and Ross are alone, Elizabeth asks him if he hates her for marrying another man. This opens up a wound, and Ross tells her the truth—that he has always loved her. He draws close to her and asks if there’s really nothing left between them now.

She clings to the excuse that she’s a married woman. Ross is pissed and he storms away. (ugh, I hate love triangles!!!)

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_17_58 AM Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_19_06 AMWhen Ross returns home, he’s greeted by an unpleasant surprise. Damelza’s father has arrived with his gang to fetch his daughter; it’s a matter of honor. But Ross refuses and gets into a fist fight. Ross wins in the end, and the men all shake hands. I guess they respect Ross for being able to fend for himself.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_19_50 AMDamelza, all the while, is hiding inside the liquor cabinet. But Ross, not knowing that she’s within hearing, says “[Damelza] appears to be more trouble than she’s worth.” Hurt, Damelza packs up, takes her dog, and decides to return home.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_22_59 AM Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_23_01 AMBut on the way, she bumps into Ross. She never wanted to leave him in the first place, so when he offers to take her back with him, she joins him on his horse.

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_23_29 AMScreenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_23_16 AMOn their way home, they meet Elizabeth. She has heard the rumor that Ross is planning to leave Cornwall (Ross’ uncle, afraid that Ross might steal Elizabeth’s heart away from his son Francis, is trying to convince Ross to leave), and she begs him to stay, reminding him that Cornwall is his home. But Ross surprises her.

Ross: Where did you think I was going?
Elizabeth: To London. Your uncle said…
Ross: My uncle’s mistaken.
Elizabeth: Then what are you doing?
Ross: I lost sight of something. I came in search of it. Having found it, I’m going home.

Ross says this while Damelza is practically in his embrace. Hmm…

.

Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 1_28_10 AMFirst Impression: It’s surprising how similar the adaptation is to the book. The only big difference is that Damelza in the TV show is a teenager/young woman, whereas in the book she first meets Ross when she’s only thirteen. While the 13-year-old Damelza was so much more adorable and funny, I’m not complaining. I’m GLAD she’s older in the adaptation. It’s less awkward to imagine them as a romantic couple that way.

So far, I’ve watched up to episode 3. And as a fellow period-drama-enthusiast told me: this show has the Jane Eyre vibes. You have the brooding hero, a young woman wiser than her age as his romantic interest, and the moody backdrop. Oh yes, and there’s the ‘other woman.’

But while the show (so far) has a bit of the Rochester-Jane vibe, it hasn’t captured the emotional poignancy or depth present in dramas like Jane Eyre (or North and South, Persuasion, Outlander, etc).

Anyway, I’d still recommend this show to any lover of period dramas. The scenery of Cornwall is stunning, the chemistry between the leads has an Outlander-ish-sizzle, and we’re given an interesting look into the business of mining. I think it’s a decent enough show, though not a great one in my book. We’ll see. My opinion might change as I watch more episodes—and yes, I’m intrigued enough to watch more. There’s enough romance and intrigue to keep me hooked.

Preview of Episode 2:


(Is it just me, or does this look like a scene snatched out from a historical romance):

 Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_43_15 AMScreenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_43_09 AM Screenshot - 2015-03-25 , 12_43_21 AM

Advertisements

8 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

8 responses to “POLDARK (Episode One): My First Impression

  1. Bookworm

    Ah, Jane you had me at “it hasn’t captured the emotional poignancy or depth present in dramas like Jane Eyre (or North and South, Persuasion, Outlander, etc).” and then lost me with “the chemistry between the leads has an Outlander-ish-sizzle”.

    I also watched all three and I am sorely disappointed with the show. It has zero “sizzle” chemistry between the leads and I don’t blame the actors for it. The casting is way off and the characters themselves feel one dimensional, wooden, just there. I found no passion in them. Even the villain is bland.

    To prove my point, just watch the first kiss between Jamie & claire and then the one with Demelza & Ross. In both scenes we have a virgin coming together with someone experienced. But what a difference in conveying the two scenes! And all do to the direction, and chemistry of the stars in the show.

    I also think if they followed the book so closely, they should have had Demelza start off as a 13 yr old, then shown us how she grew in his household, and shown us her attraction, reverence, respect and love for him grow with her age, THEN they should have shown us Eleonor as Demelza. That would have been more believable.

    I also think they’re rushing through all the important life’s incidents, therefore cramming too much facts within a short period of time, and leaving one cold and disconnected.

    I’ll try to stick to the show, but it’s hard when the enthusiasm fades with each episode.

    Mel

    BTW I Think Robin Ellis’ guest appearance was awesome. It brought many memories back, and one was how much chemistry he had with Anghard 🙂

    Like

    • Great, great insight into the adaptation! My first comment, about how the show lacked depth, holds most true to my opinion of the show. The bit about the sizzle–I should have been more clear. I only meant it in the sense that the kissing/seduction scene was more on the sensual side than, say, the ‘respectable’ kiss exchanged between Darcy and Elizabeth. I totally agree with you though, it’s NOTHING like Outlander. I think it’ll be hard for any show to reach the ‘sizzle level’ of Outlander.

      I initially liked Damelza as being older because I thought the romance would be introduced more earlier on into the story. But nope. It was rushed in. That kiss between them would have been so much better if they’d actually had some kind of emotional relationship.

      I’m going to stick to the show because I want to see how they’ll show Ross falling in love with Damelza! At this rate, it seems like Ross will always love Elizabeth a little.

      Anyway, I’m glad to know that I’m not the only one who isn’t in love with the episodes. I thought it was just me! I checked the IMDB rating and people were giving it an 8 out of 10. I think it’s more of a 7/10

      Liked by 1 person

      • Bookworm

        No, it’s not just you, but the fans are blinded by Mr. Turner [who is a dream!] but he can only deliver to the screen what the director tells him
        Same goes for Ms. Tomlinson. I saw them before in different roles, and I must admit that they are wonderful actors, yet in this role there is something missing and that something is “real emotion”.
        BTW, Mr. Selfridge comes to our shores tomite 🙂 My hubby and I are huge fans of the show so Sundays have been reserved 😉
        HUGS!

        btw 2: I’ll be watching Poldark with my hubby when it arrives here sometime in April I think and I can’t wait to hear what he thinks of it. So far he’s been hooked on Black Sails, Mr. Selfridge, Copper, Outlander [he can’t stand Vikings?!] oh and he adores The Musketeers [hates Downton?!] LOL!

        Liked by 1 person

      • I can tell that they’re good actors but, as you pointed out, I can’t seem to connect with any of the characters. I can’t connect with Ross’ love for Elizabeth; I can’t understand why he’s suddenly lusting after Damelza; and I can’t really ‘feel’ his love for his land–if he loves it at all, that is.

        I haven’t seen Mr. Selfridge yet! It seems like I’m missing out big time! I didn’t watch it because I absolutely adored Paradise and I read a few reviews claiming that Mr. S isn’t as good.

        Your husband has good taste in period dramas! I’m also not a fan of Vikings and Downton haha.

        Like

  2. Bookworm

    My apologies 😉 JUNE, not jane 🙂 Forgive me, it was a long night …

    HUGS!

    Mel

    Like

  3. I plan to watch this at some point–I watched the original miniseries a long time ago and am curious to see how they compare. Also, if they did any better on the clothing 🙂

    Fun fact–I’m named for bit characters in the second season of the original miniseries. I count myself lucky that my parents had already named the cat Demelza. (They currently have a cat named Poldark. Clearly, they liked the earlier miniseries!)

    Like

    • Let me know your thoughts when you do get the chance to watch it! I wanted to watch the original miniseries but couldn’t find it online. Maybe it’ll show up again soon?

      Oh, so you were named after a character in that series?! That’s so cool! Your parents must have really, really loved the Poldark series!! I’m glad the cat saved you–not that I dislike the name Damelza–but I can’t see you as a Damelza haha.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s